|
Traders at one of London's most popular markets are facing closure
as rents soar by up to 75 per cent.
Stallholders at the Stables Market in Camden claim they are being
driven out of business by a property consortium.
The market is a focus of London's alternative music scene and attracts
millions of tourists every year.
It was given a £12million makeover by Camden Market Holdings
Group, headed by Israeli billionaire Bebo Kobo, a friend of Chelsea
boss Roman Abramovich.
Stars including singer Kate Nash and Blur guitarist Graham Coxon
attacked this as a "pathetic attempt at modernisation"
that ruined the "edgy" ambience.
Now some of the small businesses paying £100 weekly rent have
been told to expect a rise to £175 and fear they will be replaced
by chain stores.
Chantelle Bernard, 21, who inherited a clothing stall run by her
parents for 14 years, said: "We've been told to expect a 75
per cent rent increase by this week. This could be the end as our
profit margins are only a few hundred pounds."
Traders claim the consortium is recouping its investment by adding
more than 100 new units and increasing rents.
They say managers want them to open for three more days a week,
instead of just weekends. Mr Kobo, 55, whose interests include property
in London, New York and Miami and retail, owns 50 per cent of the
Stables.
Billionaire Labour party donor Richard Caring, an entrepreneur who
owns Annabel's nightclub, and real estate firm Chelsfield Partners
each own a quarter of the market.
One seller said: "Lots of people are worried their business
won't see out the summer. It's like they are increasing the rents
on a whim." More units are under construction, including a
three-storey "mall" and underground units.
Land Registry records show the Stables Market was part of a portfolio
bought in 2001 for £49.6million by Camden Estate Holdings
Limited, which also owns the Canal Market, razed by fire last year.
Piers Codling, a partner at Chelsfield Partners, denied the consortium
wanted to replace independent stalls with larger chains.
He added: "The market is ever-evolving to ensure the right
traders are in the right place and unit. Some rents haven't increased
and some have."
Reader views (39)
CORRECTION & APOLOGIES RE PREVIOUS RESPONSE TO ANDREAS!!
I misread your post. The Stables no longer has casual stalls, only
overpriced shop units built simply for revenue, with no concern
for traders, nor for the destruction of a priceless & irreplaceable
site of British heritage.
Whilst in comparison, Camden Lock retains its originality, charm
& character with a proper & reasonably priced market.
I believe the weekend daily rate is £40-45, depending on location.
- Ex Trader, London, UK
There are no stalls anymore, only shops. You need to contact the
Stables market office who'll be eager to give you details.
Strongly advise you visit the area where you're offered a unit,
both on a weekday & a weekend, before handing over cash.
Talk to the current traders, they'll tell you the truth & explain
why there are suddenly so many available units!
- Ex Trader, London, UK
can anyone please give me some information about current prices
to rent a stall in camden lock market ?
thank you
- Andreas Kalan, st albans
TO ALL TRADERS @ STABLES/CANAL MARKET; Check your lease & you
should have a 'Tenancy at Will'. You will have been told by the
management that you have to give 2 -8 weeks notice otherwise you
will forfeit your deposit. This is NOT TRUE! Please check your facts
by googling 'Tenancy At Will' IMPORTANT FACT: "Most leases
of business premises enable the tenant to acquire security of tenure.
One of the requirements for the lease to to acquire security of
tenure is that it should be for a fixed or periodic term. Thus one
way in which this can be avoided is to create a Tenancy At Will.
This is a form of tenancy which does not have any fixed length and
neither is there any requirement for notice to be given by either
party in order to bring it to an end. it is exactly what it says
- it can be brought to an end by the will of the parties at any
time and without notice." Please check with the National Market
raders Federation if you have any queries re the above.
- Ex Trader, London, UK
we had a stall in the stables for 10 years and left in 2000 due
to rent increases and new ( D ) management by this lot in there
now who were rude , manipulative and ran the market into the ground
back then just like a mafia. it looks like now it has finally come
to the crunch, they have killed it !
- An Ex Trader, LOS ANGELES, USA
Camden markets were a wonderful spiritual expression of all thatís
creative and unique, full of diversity and peace in arts,crafts,music
and clothing indigenous of the whole concept of... The Market.....Today
due to fat fingered business ignorance the markets are becoming
clones of the same supplier...just in case the tourist was looking
away as they passed the stall.. here it is again! So to all you
developers please take note... no matter how you dress the truth
up to escape your greed..Believe me Its not rocket science...
Let me help... as Wikipedia states. A market is any one of a variety
of different systems, institutions, procedures, social relations
and infrastructures whereby persons trade, and goods and services
are exchanged..... If a trader is completely independent and unique
to the markets then they should be given a reduced rent. The big
traders that earn millions should be footing the bill...Simples!
We should be celebrating and encouraging the small trader not suffocating
them.... end of rant...Peace
- Paul, london
with regard to the comment about a all the traders leaving on mass
is not quite true. some traders decided that it was not worth selling
their houses to pay the rent or take their kids out of private school,
or to throw away money that could be better spent! I will say this
the majority of traders have a plan B in place, if and when they
need it. as the saying goes "DON'T PUT ALL YOUR EGGS IN ONE
BASKET!
- Mandy, london, UK
Re Jonny comment- "its been designed in the fashion of victorian
London - the whole area looks 200 years old!"
Ummm-I havent seen any pics of Victorian London showing big glass
fronted buildings & elevators!
- Kelly, London, UK
Hello Rich - there's a mass exodus from the Stables due to extortionate
rent hikes as you of course know, and whether the units are constructed
from cheap timber or teak is totally irrelevant.
You and your colleagues have told some traders that you are under
strict instructions from BEBO to let units to ANYONE who can afford
to pay the rents. Hence the influx of Asian traders.
Anyone doubting the truth of this should visit the market &
talk to traders who have hung on since the recent rent increases.
- Soni, London, UK
Jonny wrote, "Camden is a terrific place steeped in tradition...",
"which to me it seems the owner is trying to uphold as he only
allows independent businesses and young designers take stalls within
the market."
Fact: indeed the market is/was a terrific place- but your second
statement is patently (& visibly) untrue!!!
Firstly, there are no 'stalls' nowadays they're all shops-££
per footage equals high street rents!
Secondly, in total contradiction to your comment, please look at
the 'stalls', mostly operated by the Chinese-specially in what was
the Canal market. You'll find few shops left selling anything individual
& innovative anymore. New, young, independent designers cant
afford the rents! You will mostly find same after same 'Made in
China' sweatshop tat.
- I Love Camden, Enfield, UK
You complain it's made of cheap materials but if we'd used expenive
materials, then you would have complained we'd spent too much! How
can Stables win?
- Rich, London
In response to your comments Jonny, obviously you have a latex brain
as well as name. Just to reiterate, traders at camden have had their
rents increased by a minimum of 75% some have been hiked up by 500%.
Traders who have been part of the market for years TOLD and not
asked to move to other units promised a 3 month rent free period
only to find out that the management are asking for rent after 6
weeks and at an increased figure to what was originally agreed!!!
Making traders to sign a tenancy agrrement (very one sided management
control) that is not worth the paper it is written on. The heavies
can give notice to a trader at any time.
Get your info right regading spitalfields, it is only £80
at weekends and much cheaper in the week in accordance with foot
flow.
- Mandy, london
Seems like the article is based on a specific section of the market...
All the stalls in that area did not even exist before the new Stables
Management took over and 'created' them. Enough Said LOL
I used to have a shop in the Lock building back in the 90s and left
when the Soul really did drop out of Camden (ie when Starbucks openned
and CafÈ Brasillia closed etc). I've been coming back ever
since, hoping Camden would return to its former glory. Last year
it looked to me like the new development was working really well...
So I'm back with 2 stalls in The Stables and 1 in the Canal Market
GoodTimes!!!
- Aileen, London, England
yeah, sure, why develope? why progress? when we can stay in the
19th century. we could have stayed as monkeys on the trees and never
become humans and then everything would have been lovely, or better
yet we should have never left the oceans to become monkeys.
get a grip on yourself people, where do you think we are? the old
soviet union? you like progress as long as it got to do with YOUR
business, but when someone else developes his, you all become communist/unionists.
some traders however do not have this attitude and are actually
embracing the opertunity as they should. i guess there will allways
be people with a strong attraction to drama. the same people will
have the time to send 70 complaint letters to the council, write
10 comments to an article, but not the time to improve their business
and march it along forward, therefore are alarmed at a rent increase
that has actually left the rent cheaper then any other market in
london. why doesnt kate nash the champion of the poor and weak make
a name for herself by singing is quite clear. she simply cant, therefore
she hangs on others in a time of low publicity.
here kate, you got your picture in the evening standard, im sure
you will sell another 3 cd's today. and Graham Coxon , the new Blur
reunion needs some PR ,EH? drama queens.
- Caveman, London
To me it sounds like a load of bored, busy-body celebrities and
journalists getting off on their own sense of self importance. Did
you know that spitalfields market charges £80 per day? that
makes the £175 for 7 days that camden is charging seem a bargain.
Also modernisation? Has Kate Nash even seen the new development?
its been designed in the fashion of victorian London - the whole
area looks 200 years old! Camden is a terrific place steeped in
tradition which to me it seems the owner is trying to uphold as
he only allows independent businesses and young designers take stalls
within the market.
- Jonny, London
Personally, I think it's great, I'm all for having 3 Pizza Expresses,
4 Starbucks', 2 Greggs', 2 Costa Coffees and 3 Subways per square
metre across London.
Who needs charming individuality, when you've got homogenised, mass
produced, faceless corporations, giving that 'Hey this is just like
back home in [insert rich western country]' feeling we all know
and love.
I actually think the horses are an excellent familiar of the Market,
historically noble and strong, now a hideous, weak, over manufactured
mess.
- Matt, London
I am totally shocked at the current state of the Stables and the
lack of care by Camden Council to keep this great Victorian site
in its original form as a part of London's social History. This
is what is really going on amongst the horses!
1. during the refurbishment and building there has been a great
lack of enforced health and safety rules and regulations. For example
workmen without hard hats, hivi vests and steel capped boots. No
netting over buildings with scaffolding and work being carried out
overhead where public are walking.
2. Work has been persistantly carried out and food vendors in small
open fronted kiosks are serving food to the public. Rats and mice
are seen constantly due to building work.
3. No fire extinguishers, available water or sprinkler systems anywhere
in the market.
4. No fire access as wooden sheds have blocked the entrance.
5.Moving traders into other units and hiking up the rents to turn
their original units into restaurants.
6. Removing a complete victorian fascade and rebuilding modern units
that have been shoddily made that leak regularly.
7. Using cheap materials for refurbishment
8. Turfing out traders who originally made the Stables a cool and
innovative place to shop filled with antiques, vintage furnishings
and clothes and other interesting wares.
Camden residents and traders did not ask to have their market transformed
into southend-on-sea!
The council have been called on numerous ooccassions with NO RESPONSE
TO DATE!
- Mandy, london, UK
"Given this it seems obvious to me that Bebo Kobo's goal is
to create something other than a market, as without market traders
there can be no market.- James, London"
The most astute comment so far!
- Blakes, London
I guess the consortium's expansion program didn't consider the possibility
of a recession.
I'm not a businessman but logic says that increasing rents for existing
traders at an economic low is a negative move.
ie The traders are leaving cos they can't afford the rent increase=
more empty shops=less rent for the consortium.
Hmmmm - am I missing something?!
- Anony-Mouse, Essex
I agree, if you're going to spend thousands on horse statues, at
least the tourists have their photos taken on them, otherwise they're
an even bigger waste of money.
Out of interest, is Rich below part of the double act 'Rich and
Tony in da market'?
If rent has to increase to pay for the development, surely the consortium
couldn't afford it in the first place???
Young, creative talent should be nurtured not stamped out...
- Stall Holder, Camden
I have lived in Camden all my adult life and I find it all a bit
strange that the people what own the market can do what they want.
I have had put up with people working all night long, drunk's falling
out in the early hours of the morning, Fights and so much more.
what amazes me is that the council have let this go on without a
word do these people not realise that it is a market not a tourists
trap.
- Anon, Camden
its nothing to do with putting Big Chain shops in there, its just
greed, how else do you think they have to pay for those Monstrosity
Horses, they weren't going to pay for them, the whole place is bad
taste bad organisation.
If they had any brains they wouldn't have spent so much money on
those awful decorations. They are just like the Government they
want the poor workers to pay for their billionaire lifestyles. The
shops are really nice but how long can they stay there for with
the extortionate rents they are being asked to pay, its a shame
if we lose all those lovely shops. They lie and promise the world
and destroy people in 2 weeks.
- Beyan, Essex
Albert - although I may be wrong about Camden Council selling the
Stables, it was certainly CC who gave planning permission for this
devastation of one of the most wonderful & unique examples of
our English heritage. (Speaking of English Heritage, why have they
not protected this historic & fascinating site?)
Furthermore, having seen the hideous changes to Camden Stables,
a visitor could be forgiven believing him/herself to be in Chinatown
rather than the wonderful bohemian market he/she no doubt expected
to find.This is especially true of the Canal Market where stall
upon stall sells the same bland Chinese imported goods.
Bebo Kobo & and his consortiums have so much to be ashamed of.
But I'm sure the history of this country is of little importance
compared to fattening their wallets. Not forgetting the number of
people who have already lost their businesses, & more who certainly
will if a 75% rent increase is true.
Given this it seems obvious to me that Bebo Kobo's goal is to create
something other than a market, as without market traders there can
be no market.
- James, London
I used to love the Stables market. It was edgy, had lots of different
stalls, some rubbish, some gems. I liked the fact that it was run
down and the buildings were crumbling. You actually found genuine
bargains. They have totally ruined it. IT's the same thing time
and time again. It's boring. Stall after stall of people selling
zip bags, t shirts with the same designs on them, one after another.
Brick lane has lost its charm and has got expensive as the old stalls
are replaced by shops (although some are interesting, if stupidly
expensive), the antiques part of Greenwich has been removed. London
is a genuinely creative city. If they keep messing up parts of it
like they have the Stables etc then that creativity will start to
ebb away.
If you have to do places up, please do up the bits that are genuinely
in need of development.
This is a lesson in how to totally screw up a market. Thanks Piers
Codling for nothing. You turned a market into a mall. You will drive
the genuinely different stall holders away.
But perhaps there is an upside to all this. Perhaps all those genuinely
different stall holders that were forced from Camden, Greenwich
and Brick Lane can find a new place. There must be some patch of
ground somewhere in London with old buildings on it that would be
fit for such a use. How about a market in an old tower block? Will
deptford become the new Camden?
Whatever happens, lets keep developers like Richard Caring out of
it.
- Lee, Sydenham
Talk about playing the fiddle while Rome burns.
- Joe, Swanley Kent
"I see where some of you are coming from, but I don't know
what all the fuss is about. How else did you think the new development
would be funded?
- Rich, London"
IS THIS RICH OFF OF STABLES MARKET?
- Anon, Camden
The new development looks tacky and appalling. I was part of the
team that fought against the new development and at the council
meeting where we lost the vote. Unfortunately, because an even bigger
development had previously been agreed by short sighted councillors
a few years earlier, the current council had no choice but to grant
permission for the new building as the developers threatened to
revert to even bigger plans.
It was obvious that the net result would be an increase in rent
for traders despite assurances to the contrary. Unfortunately, it
looks like our fears were well founded.
Maybe they should have saved the money they wasted on those hideous
horse statues instead of increasing rent.
- Emma, London
Have you worked there yourself Rich? If so, don't you think everyone
pays enough rent ? ? ? Anyhow were the local traders ever given
a choice whether the new development should go through or not in
the first place?
- Amber, London
@Rich - are you missing the label? If something aint broke, you
don't fix it.
The Stables may be rough around the edges in areas, but that's what
gives it character, charm, and alluring appeal. Who wants to shop
in a sterile street full of chain stores? I don't.
- Jock, London
I see where some of you are coming from, but I don't know what all
the fuss is about. How else did you think the new development would
be funded?
- Rich, London
We are leaving after a lovely Summer in Camden, we have no choice
to leave The Stables Market and go somewhere where there is some
loyalty for traders. Good luck to everyone who is staying, you will
certainly need it. Camden market just isn't
Camden market anymore . . .
- Amber, London
Camden in one of the only alternative and just generally unique
places left to shop. It already has chain stores on the other side
of the tube station! Leave the markets alone.
The same has already happened to kensington market which years ago
was a similar place and now it is completely gone.
- Sophie, Hove
Next: Jermyn Street.
- Roz, France
James, the site is owned privately and has been since at least 1970s,
when the market was created. Camden council didn't sell it to them
or 'give it away.' This is wrong.
- Albert Shanker, Camden, NW1
Trust me Bob - I'm a trader & tourists are few & far between
nowadays. Most of those who do visit only want to photograph the
metal horses & odd statues crammed into an already overcrowded
space.
Think Disneyland on acid!
- Sherry, London
I am one of the Stables traders hit with a 75% rent increase.
Sadly I left my shop this week as it is impossible to pay such a
massive increase.
ALL traders are suffering at the moment due to the recession &
decrease in tourists.
I was head hunted a year ago from Greenwich market.
So many promises were made: I would be given a fantastically busy
location, the market would build the shop to my own design, advertising
would make Camden the No1 tourist attraction, traders make so much
money there, etc, etc...
The facts are, there are fewer tourists than ever.
Business is so bad that rent increases are unrealistic & unmanageable
so traders are now leaving in droves.
I've seen little or no advertising & heard many tourists say
they didn't even know our part of the market existed!
Once you're signed up you're virtually forgotten about - unless
you're late with a rent payment!
In the winter months business falls dramatically so that many traders
have to subsidise the rent from other sources.
I would predict that by January there will be few traders left
- Anna (Ex Stables Trader), London
This has been going on for ages, the rent rises pushed by the market
in the 90's forced many out of it. Cyberdog were forced to relocate
to new premises and open a non alcoholic bar all because the market
owners wanted it to go upmarket. You only have to look at what's
become of the market at the Dingwalls end to see what's going to
happen in the future. It'll end up all high street shops and no
cutting edge, still, I guess the tourists will like it as they're
the only ones that go there any more.
- Bob, Cheam
I'm appalled.
I've been going to the Stables Market for 12 years. It needs nothing
done to it. Piers Codling goes on about "the right traders
in the right place" - seems to me that they are already. These
rent increases smack of a veiled attempt to force the small traders
out, and eventually turn Stables Market into a clone zone, full
of chains for the fashion magazine sheep to shop in.
- Jock, London
What's been done to the Stables market is a travesty & a disgrace.
It's a chaotic & unattractive mess!
Visit the Stables & make up your own mind whether Camden Council
should have given away (Oops - I mean sold!) this wonderful site
to bulldozers & greedy developers!
- James, London
BACK TO TOP
BACK TO MAIN PAGE
|